Customer Reviews
tragic,moving account of a nations stuggle - By: Mrs. E. L. Price, 04 Feb 2005 
This was without doubt one of the most moving,sad accounts of real life history that i have ever read. As I read through the book my shock & anger at how native americans were treated at the hands of the americans intensified. To see a race of proud people reduced to the way of life they eventually had to suffer with was truly disgraceful. It illustrated the pure greed & lack of compassion for a way of life lost forever.
Obviously the book only gives the view point of native americans but then what man wouldn't fight to save his own land.For anyone interestedin native american history I would definitely recommend this book.
Heartbreaking - By: Janet, 19 Dec 2003 I first read this book at the age of 14in 1972 & its impact has remained with me ever since. This shocking & heartrending true story of what happened to the native Americans cannot fail to move you; a story of the triumph of greed & 'progress' over the simple way of life of a noble people. It makes uncomfortable reading. You will never be able to watch a Western again without feeling a pang of shame.
A STARKLY BEAUTIFUL ACCOUNT OF WHAT AMERICA LOST - By: J. C. Bailey, 19 Jun 2002 It is axiomatic that history gets written by the winners - the losers are invariably made to look like bad men or natural losers or both. The point of "Bury My Heart At Wounded Knee" is to take a history that most of us know only from the winning perspective, & narrate it from the point of view of the losers.
Brown accomplishes this objective with considerable grace & beautyin spare, elegant narrative prose & verbatim quotes from key historical personages. Not a single word is wasted on description, sermonising or misguided attempts to explain the unexplainable. The mind-boggling amount of research Brown must have undertaken into state, federal & tribal records over the years is placed entirely at the service of the narrative. This story is broken up into episodes of just the right length & pace, each one revolving around a particular campaign or leader. The author never tries to manipulate the reader's emotions, but then he never has to.
Sadly, I think (with respect) that some readers & reviewers have missed the point of this sublime work. Of course it is not objective, & of course it is not the whole story. There are two sides to every conflict, &in the so-called "Indian Wars" there were rights & wrongs committed on both sides. But it isin our nature to be partisan, to want closure to a debate, to hold a clear judgement on the heroes & villains of the piece with no shades of grey to blur our moral certainties. The popular "Cowboys & Indians" culture of our parents' & grandparents' day was securein its belief that civilised Christian values had won the day. The more politically sensitive consensus of our own day all too easily falls into the equal & opposite error of glorifying alternative cultures at the expense of our own.
If only real life workedin such simple black-and-white terms! To treat Brown's book as the definitive history of the West - especially as a school history text that at last sets the record straight & for the first time tells it like it was - would be (almost!) as misguided as basing your view of history on Hollywood blockbusters like the Cinerama epic, "How The West Was Won". The value of this book is quite different. It is an unashamedly subjective account of the sufferings endured by the First Americans at the hands of the European settlers & their government. It should be readin conjunction with the standard histories, & (in the mind's eye of the reader) juxtaposed on the images of White American legend.
Only thus, by embracing the tension between these different perspectives, can truth be served. Ultimately, Brown's book serves two valuable functions: Firstly, it provides a necessary antidote to the decades of triumphalist legend that depicted the Native Americans as little more than vindictive savages. But more than that, it gives America (and the rest of Western civilisation) a record of what it lost through the destruction of such a rich & diverse cultural heritage. Given the simultaneous loss of innocence & the environmental damage that went handin hand with the destruction, it is clear that the "winners" lost more than we have commonly grasped.
A very emotive and thought provoking subject. - By: , 16 Jun 2001 With a life-time of reading behind me I can say that without a shadow of doubt that this book has raised more emotion than anything I have ever passed my eyes over. The history of the native Red Indian has been portrayed so inaccuratly by Western Films that we have the image that they were all savages. This book by Dee Brown puts this lie to rest but does not stop there. This must be one of the finest written examples of mans inhumanity to his fellow man. A story of broken promises,lies & deceite & the planned destruction of North America's indigenous people is portraidin way that is hard to accept when you realise that this happened less than two hundred years ago. The film Dances With Wolves must be the nearest true film of the struggle of the Indian against the merciless tide of the 'New American's'. If you have never been moved by a piece of literature before, buy this book & I challenge you to read it & not be moved by the plight of a race driven to near extinction.
No emotional stone left unturned - By: J. Dennis, 03 Apr 2001 I haven't even finished reading the book yet but I can say without a shadow of a doubt that it is one of the most emotive history books I have ever read. As a student of history for many years I have rarely come across a piece of work that evokes the emotion & interest of the readerin the way this book does. A tremendous survey of the Indian frontier wars which I cannot recommend highly enough.
