Customer Reviews
Lengthy Disturbed Notes on "An excellent holdiay read" - By: Robin Guest, 16 Sep 2007 
J.A. Fletcher has a wonderfully obtuse misapprehension that the York Notes isin fact the novel itself, & at times was overshadowed by his/her lengthy disturbed delusion for what seemed to be incessant wordy misunderstandings that left you feeling wryly amused.
The passionate shallowness of this
review cannot be overlooked, that it became sometimes a tedious monologue of words that drove you into reading the next sentence was maybe its intention. You need time to absorb the heavy prose & yet you miss nothing by not ignoring the details. Eventually there is an acceptance of this pointlessness that at times left me wondering why I persevered & finished the review. Please read the actual novel & look forward to seeing the film which I am sure Mr McEwan must have had a cumbersome time bringing to a conclusion that readers of the York Notes will find sufficiently dictinct to avoid confusing with.
An excellent holdiay read - By: J. A. Fletcher, 28 Aug 2007 
This book has a wonderful story & at times was overshadowed by its lengthy disturbed wording for what seemed to be incessant descriptive passages that left you feeling impatient.
The passionate depth of this
book cannot be overlooked, that it became sometimes a tedious monologue of words that drove you into reading the next chapter was maybe its intention. You need time to absorb the intricate prose & yet you miss nothing by not absorbing the details. Eventually there is an acceptance of this narrative that at times left me wondering why I persevered & finished the book. Please read it & look forward to seeing the film which I am sure the Director must have had a cumbersome time bringing to a conclusion that the general public will find sufficiently entertaining.
This review is for the book Atonement not the (York Notes Advanced)for some reason it appearsin the wrong place, & was written originally under the correct location. Sometimes insults should be greeted with silence.
